Poker Face Season 2: The Ultimate Mystery-of-the-Week Returns on Peacock

The queen of calling out lies is back! Poker Face, the critically acclaimed case-of-the-week mystery series starring Natasha Lyonne, returns for its highly anticipated Season 2 on May 8, 2025, exclusively on Peacock.

Created by Rian Johnson (Knives Out, Glass Onion), Poker Face follows Charlie Cale, a woman with an uncanny ability to detect lies who, while on the run, stumbles upon and solves bizarre crimes across America. With season one earning critical acclaim and an Emmy nomination for Lyonne, expectations are sky-high for this next installment.

Here’s what we know so far about Poker Face Season 2, why it’s a must-watch, and what mysteries await Charlie this time around.

🎲 The Story So Far: Who is Charlie Cale?

In Poker Face, Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne) is a former casino worker who has a unique gift—she can always tell when someone is lying. After uncovering a deadly conspiracy at a Las Vegas casino, she goes on the run, traveling across the U.S. in her Plymouth Barracuda, trying to stay under the radar.

But wherever she goes, mystery seems to follow. In classic Columbo-style storytelling, each episode sees Charlie crossing paths with eccentric characters, uncovering hidden secrets, and ultimately solving strange, often murderous, crimes.

As she continues her road trip from hell, she’s also being chased by powerful enemies—including casino security chief Cliff LeGrand (Benjamin Bratt).

🕵️ What to Expect in Season 2

With Season 1 delivering ten expertly crafted mysteries, Season 2 promises more star-studded guest appearances, clever detective work, and a deeper dive into Charlie’s past and present troubles.

While Peacock has kept plot details under wraps, here’s what we can likely expect:

✔ More Wild & Unpredictable Cases – Expect more bizarre, darkly comedic, and twisted murder mysteries.

✔ A Deeper Look into Charlie’s Backstory – Season 1 hinted at Charlie’s complicated past. Will we learn more about her estranged family or past life before the casino?

✔ Bigger Threats on Her Trail – Charlie’s ability to sniff out lies and expose criminals has surely made her more enemies. Will she finally face consequences?

✔ New Guest Stars & Iconic Performances – Season 1 featured A-listers like Adrien Brody, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, and Chloë Sevigny. Season 2 is bound to deliver more top-tier cameos.

Given how Rian Johnson and Natasha Lyonne blend mystery, humor, and tension, Season 2 is shaping up to be another must-watch for fans of classic whodunits and modern thrillers.

🎭 The Cast: Natasha Lyonne & More Star Power

⭐ Natasha Lyonne as Charlie Cale – The heart and soul of the show, Lyonne’s sarcastic, sharp-witted, and street-smart Charlie remains the ultimate human lie detector.

⭐ Benjamin Bratt as Cliff LeGrand – The ruthless casino enforcer from Season 1 might still be hunting Charlie.

⭐ Simon Helberg as Luca Clark – The FBI agent with secrets of his own may play a bigger role this time around.

And of course, expect an all-new lineup of surprising guest stars, playing quirky suspects, victims, and killers.

🎬 Why Poker Face is a Must-Watch

🔎 A Fresh Take on the Classic Mystery Genre – Inspired by Columbo, each episode gives the audience a “howdunit” instead of a whodunit, making for unique storytelling and a fun ride.

🔎 Natasha Lyonne’s Unmatched Charisma – Lyonne's portrayal of Charlie is both hilarious and deeply compelling.

🔎 Rian Johnson’s Signature Mystery Style – If you loved Knives Out, Glass Onion, or Brick, you’ll love Poker Face.

🔎 Standalone Episodes, Bingeable Format – Perfect for both weekly watchers and binge-watchers alike.

📅 Release Date & Where to Watch

🔹 Premiere Date: May 8, 2025

🔹 Streaming On: Peacock

🔹 Season 1: Now streaming

🃏 Final Thoughts: Get Ready for More Twists and Turns!

If you loved Season 1’s quirky characters, smart mysteries, and Natasha Lyonne’s pitch-perfect performance, Season 2 is about to deliver even more intrigue, humor, and unexpected twists.

Whether you’re a die-hard mystery fan or just love seeing Natasha Lyonne solve crimes with style, Poker Face Season 2 is one show you don’t want to miss!

💬 What are you hoping to see in Season 2? Who do you want to guest star? Let’s chat in the comments! 🎲🔥